June 26, 2004

Brown shirts?

I've been reading references to "brown shirts" on blogs lately (Lileks, ASV, etc). What the heck does this mean? Al Gore is mentioned a lot in connection. I missed something. Can somebody clue me in?

Update: Thanks to Karl, in the comments, I understand. He points to this Wikipedia entry that has the following definition:

Today, the term "Brown Shirts" has become part of every day langugage as a term to describe the extreme rank and file of right wing organizations. It can also mean an individual of a right wing organization who is seen as very narrow-minded and excessively loyal.

As for the context with Al Gore, I followed a few links and learned that Al Gore gave a somewhat impassioned speach this week to the American Constitution Society. The transcript is here (pdf). In the first part of the speech, he gives reasoned, and reasonable, arguments about what the founding fathers meant for the Constitution to accomplish and how the President should carry out his role. In contrast to that, he mentions examples of how our current President has distorted the meaning of the Constitution and, in his view, abused his powers. For example, labeling somebody as an "enemy combatant" and holding them indefinitely without access to a lawyer. I agree with this. I don't like some of the things President Bush has done in his term. However, then Al Gore starts to get a bit emotional and, in my view, a little illogical. He calls right wing bloggers "digital Brown Shirts" and goes on and on about the illegitimacy of the Iraq war and how Bush is lying to the people.

Alles klar?

Posted by Jinglelady at June 26, 2004 09:52 AM | Politics | TrackBack
Comments

"Brown Shirts"? You mean...like Nazis?

Posted by: Duncan at June 26, 2004 10:30 AM

Not sure if there's a U.S.-specific context, but here in Europe, especially this bit of Europe, it has something to do with the "shock troops" of a political party, who don't just stop at handing out leaflets and asking for your vote - History. Torchlit rallies are also a big favourite....
http://colley.co.uk/garethjones/german_articles/under_hitler_1.htm

Posted by: neil at June 26, 2004 10:33 AM

Of course, with reference to Al Gore, it's probably just about bad dress sense.

Posted by: neil at June 26, 2004 10:34 AM

NS Stormtroopers.

http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturmabteilung - skip down to the bottom under the heading "Uniformierung und Abzeichen". Additionally, an entry in English: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brown_shirts

Posted by: Karl at June 26, 2004 02:36 PM

And what is really interesting about Gore’s “impassioned” speech is that the Bush people are equating it with speeches made by Hitler at certain rallies. It has been turned into campaign fodder. I can’t help but laugh when I see that somebody is actually going out on a limb to compare Al Gore with Hitler. Here is the link to the Gore/Hitler commerical: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/5298664/site/newsweek/

Posted by: Duncan at June 27, 2004 11:18 AM

Duncan - I believe the ad you're talking about actually uses footage where people supporting Kerry are shown likening *Bush* to Hitler. Bush's campaign is just using the whole Bush=Hitler rhetoric that the left uses to show how silly it is. I could be wrong, it's late, I haven't followed your link above, but I think I'm right. I'll follow the link tomorrow and if I'm wrong, I'll correct myself. As for info on what I'm talking about, I point you to http://asmallvictory.net/archives/007094.html.

Posted by: Anna at June 28, 2004 01:17 AM